EL CENIZO, Texas As ceiling fans puffed at the U.S. flag on the
community center wall, the dozen residents at the city council meeting
here Thursday put hands over hearts for the Pledge of Allegiance. Then
they began their town's modestly historic council meeting, possibly the
first in the U.S. to be conducted by city ordinance in Spanish.
Far-flung, sun-battered and mostly poor, this former colonia of trailers
and frail bungalows found itself in the middle of a political vortex two
weeks after enacting a pair of surprising new laws.
City Employees Forbidden From Assisting U.S. Border Patrol
Under one ordinance, all city government business must take place in
Spanish. And under the other, city employees - all six of them - are
forbidden to assist the U.S. Border Patrol in catching undocumented
immigrants. If they do so, they risk being fired.'
Not a Rejection of American Culture, But an Acknowledgement of
Realities;
"About 75% of the people here only speak Spanish"
In a town of 7,500 where virtually every resident is an immigrant, married
to an immigrant, or the child of immigrants, the laws reflect not so much
a rejection of American culture but acknowledgment of a border culture
dominated by Spanish and haunted by Border Patrol search vehicles.
Far from springing from any broad ideology, in fact, the motivation for
the two laws was utterly local, said Mayor Rafael Rodriguez. ''About 75
percent of the people at meetings here only speak Spanish,'' he said.
Political rivals of city council members had accused them of turning in
undocumented residents to the Immigration and Naturalization Service, or
INS, and the new law will help dispel such accusations, Mr. Rodriguez
added. So far, residents of this depressed town of laborers and factory
workers 10 miles (16 kilometers) down the Rio Grande River from Laredo,
Texas, have praised the two ordinances.
''I'm for it,'' said Lupe Rojas, squinting in the sunlight alongside her
10-year-old son. ''Because in English, well - no! We don't understand
it.''
Immigration-reform Advocates See the Move as a Threat
But while several Latino advocacy groups praised the effect of the
language ordinance in tailoring city services to constituents, the law
drew the ire of immigration-reform activists.
''This is not a good idea,'' said Tim Schultze, a spokesman
for U.S. English in Washington, a group devoted to making English the
official language of the United States. ''We have long predicted that this
sort of thing would happen in our country. And our opponents have said,
'You're insane. You're exaggerating. It will never happen.'''
But Lydia Camarillo, executive director of the San Antonio, Texas-based
Southwest Voter Education Registration Project, called the statute
sensible. ''It appears that these folks clearly understand these
communities do not speak English and this is a way of providing a
service,'' she said.
Under the ordinance, city council sessions and other official business
will be conducted in Spanish, and English translations will be made
available upon request within 48 hours.
'Safe Haven' Rule Apparently Violates Federal Law
While the language ordinance provokes strong debate, the ''safe haven''
rule apparently violates federal law, according to the INS. Safe haven
ordinances in cities across the country have attempted to keep municipal
employees from acting as immigration enforcers, but such measures, unlike
the one here, typically include the proviso that they be enforced within
the limits of law.
Immigration law forbids any federal, state or local government official
from restricting government entities in giving or getting immigration
information, said Bill Strassberger, an INS spokesman in Los Angeles.
However, he added, the INS had no plans to challenge the El Cenizo law.
''Other types of criminal activity are our priority,'' he said.