The influx of foreigners to New York and its suburbs and the continuing
exodus of non-Hispanic whites to other parts of the country have
transformed the face of metropolitan New York so profoundly that whites
will constitute a minority of the region's population within a few years,
demographers say.
The shift would make New York the first large metropolitan area outside
the South and West in which whites do not make up a majority, according to
an analysis of 2004 Census estimates by the Brookings Institution that was
released yesterday.
The Hispanic and Asian Populations are Increasing, While the Black
Population is Decreasing
The analysis also reveals a historic reversal: For the first time since at
least the 19th century, the black population of both the city and, to a
lesser extent, the region, has declined. In the five boroughs, according
to the estimates, the number of blacks declined by about 30,000 since
2000, dipping below 30 percent of the overall population, as the migration
of blacks to the suburbs and areas like the South outpaced immigration
from the Caribbean and Africa.
In contrast, the analysis found that while the greater New York region
over all lost 162,000 non-Hispanic whites and several hundred blacks from
2000 to 2004, the region gained 288,000 Hispanic people and 201,000 Asians
— more Asians, in fact, than any other metropolitan area.
Increasingly, the New York region's growing multiracial makeup reflects
the changing face of the inner ring of suburbs as many new immigrants
bypass the city altogether or migrate from the city to neighboring
counties after a generation or less.
What makes the city and the region unusual, though, is that among the
nation's 88 metropolitan areas with half a million or more people, New
York is one of only three — Houston and Honolulu are the others — where
the proportion of blacks, Hispanics and Asians each exceeds their share of
the national population.
Whites have been a minority in New York City since the 1980's. But now
that shift is extending to the wider metropolitan area, driven by
immigration and higher birth rates among immigrants. Already, non-Hispanic
whites are a minority of the metropolitan area's population younger than
15.
New York as the Classic Melting Pot
"New York is still the classic melting pot, with a whole diverse array of
immigrants coming in, but the suburbs are now becoming part of this bigger
melting pot," said William H. Frey, the Brookings Institution demographer
who conducted the analysis. "The suburbs are now tasting this new
diversity."
His analysis found that whites declined to 52.2 percent of the population
in 2004 from 54.2 percent in 2000 in the census-defined metropolitan area,
which includes the city, Long Island, the northern suburbs, northern New
Jersey and northeastern Pennsylvania, but not Connecticut.
"We went down 2.1 percent from 2000 to 2004," Dr. Frey said. "If we go
another 2 percent before the end of the decade, you're there." He added:
"The suburbs are now contributing to this. They've all shown a decline in
the percent of whites since 1990."
The approaching statistical milestone in the New York region has not been
unexpected by demographers.
"What this shows is that the pattern is spreading out," said Andrew A.
Beveridge, a demographer at Queens College of the City University of New
York, "and the non-Hispanic white population is continuing to dwindle."
Distinctions Between the City and 'Inner-Ring' Suburbs are
Declining
"The New York metropolitan area is becoming more like the city, and the
nation's metropolitan areas are becoming more like New York," Dr.
Beveridge said.
The trend was foreshadowed in an earlier analysis by New York's Department
of City Planning, which found that while the region's ethnic and racial
numbers had been driven for several decades by changes in the five
boroughs, those changes were also being mirrored in the suburban counties
closest to the city.
"The inner-ring suburbs are emulating the city," said Joseph J. Salvo,
director of the department's population division.
What's happening in New York has already occurred in metropolitan areas in
the West and South, including Los Angeles, Miami, Houston and San
Francisco.
The proportion of whites has also dipped to just over a majority in the
San Diego, Washington, Dallas and Las Vegas metropolitan regions as Asian
and Hispanic people disperse beyond central cities and their suburbs and
as blacks migrate to the South. In each of those areas, whites are already
a minority of the population under age 15.
Atlanta led large metropolitan areas in black population growth and is
poised to overtake Chicago as the region with the second-highest black
population in total numbers, after New York.
In 1990, metropolitan Los Angeles and New York accounted for 30 percent of
the nation's Hispanic population. By 2004, those two regions were home to
only 23 percent of Hispanic people.
"For immigrant minorities, especially, friendship and family networks have
drawn them to traditional ports of entry, even during times when labor
market considerations would suggest they move elsewhere," Dr. Frey wrote.
"Blacks, as well, have tended to follow well-worn patterns, initially out
of the South and, later, to a network of cities across the North and
West."
But more recently, he concluded, "many lower-skilled Hispanic migrants are
moving to fast-growing areas of the country, in response to retail,
service and construction job growth, while higher-skilled minority
migrants are following the same professional opportunities that have
attracted whites."