What Is 'Popular Culture'?
FAST-US-7 United States Popular Culture (Hopkins)
Department of Translation Studies, University of Tampere
"Popular culture" may be defined as the differing forms of expression and
identity which are characteristic of a particular society (whether
local, regional, national, racial or ethnic, to mention only a few of the
different definitions of "society" itself). Such forms of expression are
how the "people" in such societies interact with each other; collectively,
they form the "culture" via which the the people identify themselves and
their relations with each other. In this sense, popular culture is
closely related to folk culture (see below.)
More specific definitions of "popular culture" differ considerably
between the Humanities and the Social Sciences, in particular Media
Studies. Media researchers and most journalists and the general
public which journalism influences consider "popular culture" to
be mainly mass media products, such as television shows, films,
recordings, and popular literature (in the wide sense of the mass
distribution of any printed material, including journalism, cartoons,
comics, advertising posters, etc., in addition to romance novels or
detective fiction). Thus the study of popular culture within Media Studies
focuses on genres such as situation comedies, film noir, best-selling
novels, or rap music.
The Humanities includes such "mass media" products in its own
definition of popular culture, but does not restrict its definition to
them. In the Humanities perspective the various aspects
of popular culture which are not conveyed by mass media are also included,
including such things as clothing styles, fads, holidays and celebrations,
amusement parks, both amateur and professional sports, folklore and
folkways, popular rituals, artifacts of material culture, and a wide range
of other phenomena which also define the identities and interrelationships
of people in a given society.
The International Dimension of Popular Culture Study
The "material" of popular culture, regardless of how one defines it, is
usually studied from the perspectives of the social and cultural contexts
in which the materials are created, disseminated, interpreted, or used.
In the case of US-7, a second dimension emerges. The materials of
American popular culture may have been created within the domestic
American culture, but "used" or "received" in Finland, within a cultural
context that may understand (or mis-understand) American materials in very
different ways from how their "originators" intended. When examining
popular culture from an international perspective, one should always
reflect on the differing ways in which creator and consumer may view the
same material and the reasons and implications behind these. (See
also
'Finnish Mother nuture'.)
Popular Culture as a Discipline
Although the study of popular culture has a long history, scholars
disagree about when it began. Those who equate popular culture with mass
media claim that popular culture did not exist before the Industrial
Revolution, the rise of a large middle-class segment of society, and the
emergence of efficient commercial printing.
Humanities scholars, in particular social historians, consider "popular
culture" to refer to the expressive materials of any group, large or
small, pre-industrial or post-industrial. Thus popular culture scholarship
also includes pre-industrial expressive forms.
In recent years the study of popular culture has greatly expanded in
most disciplines. Social and cultural historians, for instance, attempt to
recover aspects of past everyday life that have frequently been left out
of 'classic' historical records by examining popular festivals, carnivals,
rituals, and celebrations, among other phenomena. Likewise,
anthropologists have been turning to the ethnographic study of
contemporary culture, including popular music. Folklorists often study
the popular co-opting of aspects of "folk culture" by mass culture.
Despite the diversity of disciplinary background and focus, popular
culture studies shares the common belief that all materials which are
genuinely "popular" are socially significant regardless of whether
members of the society personally approve of or enjoy any particular item
or genre. The continuing controversies in almost all modern societies over
such things as censorship, rock music lyrics, and the content of music
videos alone are clear evidence that people recognize the impact and
significance of these and other forms of popular culture.
Differences Between Popular and Folk Culture
What are some examples of the distinctions between popular and folk
culture? Consider the following:
- Popular culture comprises the means via which large, heterogeneous
masses of people identify themselves, for example by conformity to certain
types of dress, ways of speaking, modes of behavior, music preferences,
etc.;
- The norms of popular culture are highly individualistic and constantly
changing they allow adherents to continually update or redefine
themselves by the culture aspects they adopt, maintain, modify, or reject;
- There are strong commercial interests in popular culture. Folk-culture
objects give way to their popularized "equivalents" which are more quickly
or cheaply produced and more profitable;
- Consuming these "popular culture products" often enhances prestige as
well as identity whether via certain types of music, dress,
hairstyle, dialect or jargon, etc.
- Popular culture is often transmitted by mass media such as books,
films, television, large public gatherings (rock concerts, mass sports
events, etc.) and is usually not location-specific.
- One's "identity" within popular, mass culture is usually flexible and
even vague, with a wide range of possible social roles which one may
define individually within the broad cultural norm. Popular culture
identity is seldom restricted to any particular environment (including
national environments).
In turn, folk culture might be characterized as follows:
- Folk culture comprises people (and objects, etc.) who represent or
maintain a "traditional" mode of life who live in an old-fashioned
way or with a simpler life-style which is not (or no longer) "popular" (at
least in the modern, "mass" sense prevailing in a particular society);
- Folk culture is usually rural, cohesive, conservative, and largely
self-sufficient. There is often a strong family or clan structure and
highly developed family, religious, or general community rituals;
- Tradition is paramount change comes infrequently and slowly
- Individualism is subordinate to traditional community standards and
values;
- Commercialization is not characteristic of folk culture, although
aspects of folk culture may be co-opted or copied and popularized (and
thus commercialized) by mass culture.
- Folk culture may combine folk and nonfolk elements. Such may be
either (or both) material and nonmaterial:
- Material culture includes all objects or “things” made and used by
members of a particular cultural group material elements are
concrete, and visible
- Nonmaterial culture, including folklore, is largely compriseds of
"oral tradition," including folktales, folksongs, folkdance, folklore,
folk beliefs, superstitions, and customs. Other aspects of nonmaterial
culture include dialects, religions, and particular "worldviews."
- Folk culture is usually transmitted interpersonally within the
relatively small, cohesive, homogeneous society in question; and is often
confined to that particular environment;
- The "identity" of members of a folk society is usually fixed and
inflexible, with clearly-defined role expectations
Other Distinctions Between Popular and Folk Culture
As noted above, Humanists consider folk culture to be a subset of popular
culture. Social scientists often do not include folk culture in their
definition of "popular culture", except to the extent that aspects of it
have been co-opted and "popularized" by mass culture.
One might conclude the following about the relationship between folk
and popular culture:
- Popular culture is individualistic, flexible as to identity,
constantly-changing, broadly-spread, commercial in nature, and
wide-ranging in both scope and appeal.
- Folk culture is traditional, relatively inflexible and resistant of
change, local in orientation, non-commercial, and limited in the appeal of
its authentic, original form to "outsiders" of the particular society;
- Popular culture always challenges folk culture; seldom does it happen
in reverse;
- Popular culture undermines folk culture; seldom the reverse;
- Popular culture often appropriates elements of folk culture. Folk
culture may appropriate elements of the larger popular culture
around it, though this is less frequent, usually less-visible, and usually
by reason of force majeure;
- Popular culture markets those elements of folk culture which it has
co-opted and "popularized"; this usually results in the gradual
disappearance of the "original" forms of the folk culture elements.
Characteristics of Mass Popular Culture
"Mass" popular culture (films, recordings, popular literature, television
programming, and other large 'mediated' events), has been described by
Emeritus Professor Bill Stott of UT-Austin as follows (Spring 2004):
- Popular culture is by nature commercially successful, self-sustaining
and self-perpetuating: it pays for itself;
- Popular culture produces masses of spectator-participants who form a
community of 'believers' or 'adherents' to the culture they are consuming;
- Participation in such communities can have a powerful identity role,
rivalling that of racial or ethnic group membership.
- Certain forms of popular culture are characteristic only of certain
racial or ethnic (or even religious, etc.) groups. Participating in the
culture reinforces one's identity within that group;
- Popular culture celebrates the people who are experiencing it;
- Popular culture is the "glue" which binds members of a common society;
- Popular culture can be revolutionary in effect, though often
unintentionally;
- Popular culture is always looking for the "new" (cf. the emphasis on
"newness" and "freedom" in advertising);
- However, the "new" cannot be really new this is instead the
function of art. Popular audiences would not understand totally new
artifacts. [This explains why popular culture so often co-opts material
from folk culture.]
Why are some 80% of all films worldwide either made or produced in the
U.S.? Why is American popular music so popular globally? Apart from
factors like availability and pricing, the following are also relevant:
- Most U.S. popular culture is produced in English, which is not only
understood globally, but itself often has a popular status identification
in countries where it is not the native language. The ability to
participate in English-language culture itself may lend status. The
consumption of popular culture from English-speaking countries like the
U.S. allows one to identify oneself with what that culture "means" for
that person.
- Both the creators of U.S. popular culture and its audiences have a
hybrid vigor, representing highly multicultural elements. Just as the
U.S. population is comprised of people from almost all other countries
on the globe, so can people from almost any other country find something
in U.S. popular culture which is to them familiar with which they
can identify;
- A corollary of this is that, being highly multicultural, U.S. popular
culture has a broad appeal to the emerging "global culture" (as distinct
from any one of its components);
- The promise of popular culture is individual happiness, which also is
the focus of American society e.g. "life, liberty, and the pursuit
of happiness." It is thus not a surprise that popular culture material
which celebrates individualism and happiness originates in the U.S.
Top
Notes Index
US-7 References Index
US-7 Web Links
US-7 Schedule
Last Updated 17 January 2010
|